The Scottish heritage watchdog, Historic Environment Scotland (HES), has been under scrutiny for its governance practices, which have been deemed 'unacceptable' by the Auditor General, Stephen Boyle. The report highlights a series of issues, from procurement problems and data breaches to concerns over complimentary tickets and a lack of transparency in leadership. But here's where it gets controversial: the report also touches on allegations of corruption, an internal racism row, and the suspension of the body's chief executive, Katerina Brown, amidst an investigation into her conduct. This has raised questions about the organization's culture and the need for a thorough review. The HES chairman, Sir Mark Jones, acknowledged the ongoing investigations and the need for a fresh start in the new year. With an independent review of its structure, efficiency, and culture on the horizon, HES aims to address these failings and rebuild trust. But what does this mean for the future of HES? And how will these issues impact the organization's ability to maintain its historic sites and promote heritage tourism? These are the questions that remain to be answered as HES navigates this challenging period.